02 Lab experiment
The Harmony Machine
Pendulums swing a funnel of sand with an LED on it over a steel plate that a speaker sets ringing. Pick an interval: the light, the sand, the plate’s lines and the chord all show the same ratio.
Hanging the pendulums…
Two pendulums, a funnel, a plate and a camera
Two pendulums tied into one swing a funnel of sand over a steel plate. A speaker under the plate makes it ring, and a camera overhead keeps its shutter open for the whole swing.
- 01
Pendulums
Two lengths, two frequencies, one looping path. A third pendulum circles at almost the root’s pace and slowly turns the figure; switch it off and the figure holds still.
- 02
Sand
The funnel drips a thin, steady stream, so sand heaps up where the swing slows at the turns and thins out where it rushes through the middle.
- 03
Light
An LED on the funnel’s rim faces the camera and draws the same path in light, brightest where the swing lingers.
- 04
Plate
Where the plate shakes hard it throws the sand about; where it is still, the sand stays. Over a minute the drawing breaks up, slides and gathers on the still lines.
- 05
Camera
One exposure, from the first swing to the last. The light adds up; the sand is whatever is left on the plate when the shutter closes.
You end up with three things: a photograph (Save the photograph), a sand piece (Sweep the plate to start again), and the performance itself, which you can listen to (Hear the chord).
Every layer shows the same two numbers
A musical interval is a ratio of two whole numbers. In a perfect fifth the upper note vibrates three times for every two of the lower: 3:2. The machine uses those two numbers four times over.
- Light
The pendulums swing at 3:2, so the LED draws the 3:2 Lissajous figure: it touches the top and bottom three times for every two times it reaches the sides.
- Sand
The funnel lays the same figure down in sand, heaped where the swing slows.
- Plate
The plate rings in its (3, 2) mode: three half-waves across and two down, mixed with the same wave turned on its side. Its still lines are where the sand ends up.
- Sound
The speaker plays A3 and E4, 220 and 330 Hz. Three to two.
The pendulums are the same chord nine octaves down. 220 Hz ÷ 512 is 0.43 Hz, one swing every 2.3 seconds, which takes a 1.35 m string; E4 comes down to 0.64 Hz and 0.60 m. A pendulum’s length goes as one over its frequency squared, so the two lengths are in the ratio 9:4: the interval, squared.
| Interval | Ratio | Chord | Pendulums | Plate mode |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Octave | 2:1 | A3 + A4220 + 440 Hz | 1.35 m · 0.34 m | (2, 1) |
| Perfect fifth | 3:2 | A3 + E4220 + 330 Hz | 1.35 m · 0.60 m | (3, 2) |
| Perfect fourth | 4:3 | A3 + D4220 + 293.3 Hz | 1.35 m · 0.76 m | (4, 3) |
| Major sixth | 5:3 | A3 + F♯4220 + 366.7 Hz | 1.35 m · 0.48 m | (5, 3) |
| Major third | 5:4 | A3 + C♯4220 + 275 Hz | 1.35 m · 0.86 m | (5, 4) |
| Minor third | 6:5 | A3 + C4220 + 264 Hz | 1.35 m · 0.93 m | (6, 5) |
Why a piano’s fifth slowly turns the figure
A piano doesn’t play pure ratios. It splits the octave into twelve equal steps, so every interval but the octave is slightly off. Switch the tuning to Equal and you can watch the error.
The piano’s fifth is 1.96 cents flat (a cent is a hundredth of a semitone). The third harmonic of A3 and the second harmonic of E4 should both sit on 660 Hz; instead they are 0.74 Hz apart, so the chord beats, a slow pulse about three times every four seconds. The pendulums carry the same error nine octaves down, so the figure slowly rolls through all its shapes, once every 11½ minutes. Turn the time-lapse up to 12× to see it in under a minute.
The thirds and sixths are 14 to 16 cents out. They beat 9 to 12 times a second, the faint shimmer in a piano chord, and their figures roll over in under a minute even at normal speed.
| Interval | Off by | Chord beats | Figure rolls over every |
|---|---|---|---|
| Octave | 0 cents | None | Never |
| Perfect fifth | −1.96 cents | 0.74 Hz | 11 min 27 s |
| Perfect fourth | +1.96 cents | 0.99 Hz | 8 min 35 s |
| Major sixth | +15.64 cents | 9.98 Hz | 51 s |
| Major third | +13.69 cents | 8.73 Hz | 59 s |
| Minor third | −15.64 cents | 11.87 Hz | 43 s |
A real harmony machine, from things people already make
Sand pendulums, Chladni plates and long exposures are all things people already build at home. Put together, they make a real harmony machine.
- 01
Hang a Y. Two hooks in a beam, a cord from each tied together at a knot, and one cord from the knot down to the funnel. For a fifth, make it 1.35 m from the beam to the funnel and 0.60 m from the knot to the funnel. Slide the knot to change the interval.
- 02
Fill the funnel. A plastic funnel or a paper cone with a 2 to 3 mm hole, and fine, dry sand: sieved play sand, or salt. Tape a small battery LED to the rim, facing up.
- 03
Ring the plate. A square of thin steel or aluminium, 25 to 30 cm across, bolted at its centre to a mechanical wave driver run from an amplifier and a tone generator. Sweep the tone until the sand jumps into a figure: each figure is one of the plate’s own notes.
- 04
Play the chord. From a second speaker, so the room hears the interval the pendulums are drawing.
- 05
Open the shutter. Camera on the beam looking straight down, a dark room, a dim lamp off to one side for the sand. Bulb mode, low ISO, a small aperture and a remote release. Open it, let the funnel go, and close it when the swing dies.
Chladni, Blackburn and Lissajous on one plate
Every layer of the machine is an old experiment. Each one showed a single layer of the sound; this page runs all four on one plate.
- 1787
Ernst Chladni draws a violin bow along the edge of a plate covered in sand and publishes the figures in Entdeckungen über die Theorie des Klanges (Discoveries in the Theory of Sound).
- 1844
Hugh Blackburn, a Scottish mathematician, describes the Y-shaped pendulum: the simplest harmonograph.
- 1857
Jules Lissajous fixes mirrors to two tuning forks at right angles and bounces a beam of light off both, throwing the figure their ratio makes onto a screen.
- Later
Harmonographs with pens and pendulums become a Victorian parlour favourite: a way to see harmony.